I don't want to spend too much time leading in this topic, so I'll just go there. Suffice it to say, today was a good day and one that yielded a number of questions. Here are a couple of my actual notes that I'll share with you:
-Do these people know how much a lobbyist cost?
-Can we pool resources?
-Including from folks we disagree with?
-Can the lobbyist be a young person?
-Youth Ministry and Prison Ministry (write about the parallels)
et cetera...So you can see that the brain has been working hard. In a social justice conference for black ministers I've had to work through my own definition of Justice, my sincere appreciation yet concern for prophetic tradition, and how an ethics analysis is necessary at every level of ministry (ask me about this the next time you see me). Ethics makes my bones tingle, so you'll understand why I had some questions about a certain part of tonight's service.
Jeremiah Wright Jr. preached tonight and he was awesome; talked about Unity (ethical). BEFORE THIS HOWEVER, there was two hours of service (unethical) which included an offering that lasted about...well...too long. Included in this offering was a call for $20,000 (c. COGIC) which, after little response (I mean, they did ask everyone to give $1,000 yesterday; seminarians could give up to $100. I gave NOTHING jack)...anyway...after little response they announced that they would swipe credit cards.
Credit Cards.
Nobody said much of anything during the service, which got me to wondering: Isn't this ethic at least questionable? Why is nobody storming out of the tent (yes, tent revival) proclaiming their prophetic witness? Doesn't this sound a bit like the Megachurch CEO's that these folks are essentially condemning? Credit cards? $20,000?
Is this questionable? For some I believe NO, it was just fine. But if it is, oh prophets and lovers of justice, why didn't anyone at least ASK THE QUESTION? Why didn't at least ONE of the hundreds of pastors in the room stand up and say "Isn't this questionable?" Were they afraid to stand out and cause distress? Why not just stand up and leave? Or do something, anything but WATCH. That is, if this is problematic.
FORGET theological language, for me this is an issue because of the psychological, emotional, and social manipulation of humans. It's an exercise of the coercive power of the pulpit (the downside of any charismatic tradition). And folks are going on this. I wasn't in the room when this happened, but I SWEAR it's irking me, I'm confused about the room's response, and deep down I know this "prophetic begging" is wrong.
And I never call anything WRONG. My .02. Dive in anywhere